Before joining WWE, Curt Hennig wrestled in the AWA, where he won the AWA World Heavyweight Championship, defeating Nick Bockwinkel at AWA SuperClash II.
Hennig's reign as AWA World Heavyweight Champion from May 1987 to May 1988 was the seventh-longest reign in the history of the championship, and it showcased his ability to carry a promotion as the face of the company, demonstrating not only Hennig's in-ring skills but also his ability to generate interest. WWE, JCP, and the AWA were considered the "Big Three" of the industry, with AWA programs broadcast on ESPN. However, Hennig's early success gave many the impression that he was destined for even greater things on a larger stage. With a dominant AWA reign on Hennig's resume, July 1988 was when it was time for him to move on to WWE's grander stage- where he could make more money, receive broader exposure, and where the Mr. Perfect gimmick was born.
The Mr. Perfect character was a masterpiece of execution and presentation. Curt Hennig portrayed a conceited athlete who claimed to be perfect at everything he did, from playing basketball and golf to bowling the perfect game and, of course, wrestling. Vignettes promoted the gimmick, showcasing Hennig’s “perfection” in various sports, which were brilliantly produced and added a unique dimension to his character.
The inspiration for the Mr. Perfect gimmick was that during a meeting with Vince McMahon prior to Hennig joining WWE, McMahon asked him "What do you like to do?", and Hennig replied that he was good at everything he did.
Curt Hennig was a master technician, capable of having a great showing no matter the style of wrestler he was in the ring with. Hennig's feud with Hulk Hogan proved Hennig was a perfect foil for a top face champion. It was common to see Hogan defend the WWE Championship against powerhouses like Andre The Giant, King Kong Bundy, and Kamala, with it being made clear that Hogan could overcome that style of wrestler. However, unlike the powerhouses, Hennig was faster and more agile than Hogan, and would blend technical expertise with heelish tactics. And on top of that, Hennig had been undefeated until November 1989. Coming off an undefeated streak that lasted over a year combined with his excellent wrestling technique made Hennig a distinctive opponent for Hogan and a legitimate threat to his WWE Championship reign.
Hennig’s style enabled fans to see Hogan wrestle a faster-paced match than they often would, his powerhouse opponents replaced by a more energetic wrestler. Hennig's rapid counters and fluid movement gave Hogan the opportunity to show that he could wrestle with an athletic-based wrestler just as well as he could wrestle with a power-based one.
Given Curt Hennig’s previous undefeated streak and his ability to push Hulk Hogan to the limit in their matches, it’s easy to see why many believed Mr. Perfect was world championship material. He had the talent, charisma, reputation, and popularity to be a legitimate main eventer. Considering this, the question is often posed: why didn't he ever have a world title run in WWE? Bruce Prichard, who worked for WWE during the time Hennig was feuding with WWE Champion Hulk Hogan, revealed on his podcast, Something to Wrestle with Bruce Prichard (episode #304), "Hennig was pitched as being a WWE Champion and Hennig was somebody that we all felt could have carried the championship". However, during the 1980s and early 90s, WWE operated as a "face territory," meaning the top championship was primarily held by a face, which is very different from the WWE of today, where top heels have held a top championship for long stretches. Vince McMahon’s philosophy revolved around creating larger-than-life heroes who would hold the WWE Championship for extended periods while facing a rotating cast of strong heels, whose role was to be obstacles for the face to conquer. Hogan was the company's biggest star and top face, so his feuds were built around overcoming heels. Meanwhile, Hennig was a strong heel, and although he was popular, it was a different kind of popularity than being a face- Hennig wasn't popular in the sense that many fans were cheering him and buying Mr. Perfect merchandise because they admired him, Hennig instead was popular because he was very good at being a heel and respected for his proficiency in the ring. Because the champion needed to be a face the audience rooted for, and because Hennig was a classic heel, it would have gone against McMahon's established booking philosophy at the time to have Hennig defeat Hogan for the championship. Rather than represent the company, Hennig's role was to be a strong challenger for Hogan to defeat, further solidifying his position as the dominant, much-loved face champion. This philosophy is a major reason why Hennig, despite his talent, never won the WWE Championship.
Keeping in mind that WWE was a face territory, one possible path to Curt Hennig becoming WWE Champion could have been via his January 15, 1990 match with Hulk Hogan on WWF on MSG Network. In reality, Hennig won by disqualification due to The Genius’ interference. But imagine if that interference had led to a pinfall victory instead, making Mr. Perfect the new WWE Champion, who would then begin defending the championship against Hulk Hogan and others at non-televised events in the following weeks.
With Curt Hennig as WWE Champion, WWE’s booking in early 1990 would have shifted. Instead of Hulk Hogan facing Randy Savage on The Main Event III on February 23, 1990, WWE could have booked a rematch: Hulk Hogan vs. Curt Hennig for the WWE Championship. Hogan, determined to reclaim the title, would have defeated Hennig and won back the championship, reestablishing himself as the face champion of WWE. This change would have delayed the setup for WrestleMania VI. In real life, after Hogan and Ultimate Warrior crossed paths at Royal Rumble 1990, Hogan issued The Ultimate Challenge to Warrior on February 3, 1990. However, under this scenario, Hogan wouldn’t put forth the challenge until February 24, 1990, after reclaiming the championship. On that same day, WWE President Jack Tunney would officially announce Hogan vs. Warrior as the main event of WrestleMania VI, with both the WWE Championship and Intercontinental Championship on the line. While Hennig’s reign would have been brief, it would have further solidified him as a credible world champion. Hennig would have joined the ranks of WWE Champions and been remembered as one of the few to defeat Hulk Hogan for the championship. Even with a short reign, a WWE Championship victory would have added a defining milestone to Hennig’s career, adding to his believability as a main eventer.
While WWE rarely booked heel champions for short transitional reigns in this era, Ric Flair’s two 1992 WWE Championship runs lasted 41 days and 77 days, showing that the company's stance was shifting by this point. This possibly indicates that even though Curt Hennig could not be a long-term champion, WWE may have pulled the trigger on him having a 39 day reign if it had been pitched. Hennig would have given Hulk Hogan a fresh obstacle before WrestleMania VI, and even with a short reign, defeating Hogan for the WWE Championship would have cemented Hennig as more than a prominent challenger.
Though Curt Hennig never captured the top prize, he still left a lasting impact in WWE. Hennig's two reigns as WWE Intercontinental Champion are highlights of his career that were highly regarded, especially Hennig's second reign, which was -just like his reign as AWA World Heavyweight Champion- the seventh-longest reign in the championship's history. Hennig's alumni page on WWE's official website states, "He brought the Intercontinental Title a new level of credibility during his two reigns and set a higher standard for technical wrestling in WWE when he defended the championship against Bret Hart at SummerSlam 1991." Hennig's Intercontinental Championship reign shifted it from a stepping stone for future stars to a showcase for the best technical wrestlers in the company, as he demonstrated a level of in-ring excellence that fans still talk about today and influenced later technical wrestlers.
As impressive as Hennig's performance obviously was, it's even more impressive when the fact is considered that he was wrestling in this match with a pre-existing back injury. That injury was a major setback, as this was Hennig's final match until 1992.
When Curt Hennig returned to the ring in 1992 (as a face), WWE was prioritizing its currently-established main event scene. Also, his back issue likely made WWE hesitant to invest a lot in Hennig, thinking the possibility was high that his back would get injured again. In fact the occurrence of a back issue led to Hennig leaving WWE in 1994. When he returned in 1995, it was as an announcer instead of a wrestler.
After leaving WWE in 1996, Curt Hennig made a surprise return at Royal Rumble 2002, entering at #25 and delivering a notable performance. He was one of the final three competitors and fans responded positively to Hennig's return, sparking speculation about whether he could make a serious run in the company once again. Following the Rumble, Hennig won many matches, but most of them were either dark matches or at non-televised WWE events. One key reason why he was not pushed into a major role was the company's creative direction at the time. WWE was still adjusting after the end of the Attitude Era and the WCW/ECW Invasion storyline, focusing heavily on WWE Superstars like The Undertaker, Triple H, and The Rock. While Hennig still had the charisma and in-ring ability to contribute, WWE’s priorities were on further solidifying the current roster at that time rather than focusing on returning talent. It's worth noting that Hulk Hogan, Kevin Nash, and Scott Hall had also returned that year, and unlike Hennig, were heavily featured. But Hogan's nostalgia appeal was at a level where he was a bigger draw than most of WWE's current roster at that time.
As for Kevin Nash and Scott Hall, while they had originally performed in WWE as Diesel and Razor Ramon, their time in WCW as part of the nWo had reshaped their identities in the eyes of WWE's Creative Writing Team. When WWE brought them back in 2002, they were positioned as Vince McMahon's henchmen who had been in WCW rather than returning stars, giving WWE's audience something new. By contrast, Curt Hennig was the same Mr. Perfect who been in WWE during the early '90s.
Later that year, Curt Hennig was released, bringing an end to his final WWE run. While short-lived, Hennig's return showed flashes of the greatness that made fans believe he could have been a WWE Champion had circumstances played out differently earlier in Hennig's career.
Although the reasons make sense, the absence of the WWE Championship on Curt Hennig's resume seems like a significant missed opportunity. He had a complete package of promo skills, charisma, in-ring skills, and the ability to connect with the audience. Hennig was a true main event-worthy talent who, for various reasons, never reached the very top of the mountain.
Curt Hennig’s legacy is one of indisputable talent, perfect execution, and a sense of untapped potential. He is remembered as one of the greatest Intercontinental Champions of all time and a performer who consistently delivered exceptional performances. While Hennig did not hold the WWE Championship, his influence on the wrestling world is undeniable, making him one of the best to never hold the top gold.
No comments:
Post a Comment